USPTO Examiner HUANG WEN - Art Unit 2872

Recent Applications

Detailed information about the 100 most recent patent applications.

Application NumberTitleFiling DateDisposal DateDispositionTime (months)Office ActionsRestrictionsInterviewAppeal
18755732FOLDED CAMERA LENS DESIGNS INCLUDING EIGHT LENSES OF +-+-+++- REFRACTIVE POWERSJune 2024April 2025Allow1021NoNo
18754283FOLDED MACRO-TELE CAMERA LENS DESIGNS INCLUDING SIX LENSES OF ++-+-+ OR +-++-+, SEVEN LENSES OF ++-++-+, OR EIGHT LENSES OF ++-++-++ REFRACTIVE POWERSJune 2024May 2025Allow1021YesNo
18645450LOW TOTAL TRACK LENGTH LENS ASSEMBLY INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF +-+-++- REFRACTIVE POWERS FOR LARGE SENSOR FORMATApril 2024October 2024Allow611YesNo
18594059PHOTOGRAPHING OPTICAL LENS ASSEMBLY INCLUDING EIGHT LENSES OF +-+--++-, +-++-++-, ++++-++- OR +-+-+-+- REFRACTIVE POWERS, IMAGING APPARATUS AND ELECTRONIC DEVICEMarch 2024December 2024Allow901YesNo
18586107IMAGING OPTICAL LENS ASSEMBLY INCLUDING NINE LENSES OF -++-++-+-, ++-++--+-, -+-++--+-, -+-++-++-, +--++--+- OR +--++-++- REFRACTIVE POWERS, IMAGE CAPTURING UNIT AND ELECTRONIC DEVICEFebruary 2024March 2025Allow1201NoNo
18412545FOLDED MACRO-TELE CAMERA LENS DESIGNS INCLUDING SIX LENSES OF ++-+-+ OR +-++-+, SEVEN LENSES OF ++-++-+, OR EIGHT LENSES OF ++-++-++ REFRACTIVE POWERSJanuary 2024April 2024Allow301NoNo
18544852PHOTOGRAPHING OPTICAL LENS ASSEMBLY INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF +-++--+, +---+-+, +--+--+, +--++-+, +-+---+ OR +-+-+-- REFRACTIVE POWERS, IMAGE CAPTURING DEVICE AND ELECTRONIC DEVICEDecember 2023March 2025Allow1501YesNo
18525621OPTICAL PHOTOGRAPHING LENS ASSEMBLY COMPRISING NINE LENSES OF VARIOUS REFRACTIVE POWERS, IMAGE CAPTURING UNIT AND ELECTRONIC DEVICENovember 2023October 2024Allow1101NoNo
18386154OPTICAL LENS SYSTEM, IMAGE CAPTURING UNIT AND ELECTRONIC DEVICE COMPRISING NINE LENSES OF VARIOUS REFRACTIVE POWERS, OR TEN LENSES OF -+--+-+-+- OR ++--+-+-+- REFRACTIVE POWERSNovember 2023August 2024Allow1001YesNo
18378115OPTICAL IMAGE LENS ASSEMBLY, IMAGE CAPTURING UNIT AND ELECTRONIC DEVICE INCLUDING NINE LENSES OF +--+---+-, +-+++--+-, +---++-+-, +--+++-+- OR +--+-+-+- REFRACTIVE POWERSOctober 2023July 2024Allow901YesNo
18375662OPTICAL DISPLAY SYSTEM WITH REGIONALLY ADDRESSABLE ELECTROCHROMIC LIGHT MODULATOROctober 2023May 2024Allow700YesNo
18238204OPTICAL IMAGING SYSTEM COMPRISING FOUR LENSES OF --+-, +-+-, +++- OR -++- REFRACTIVE POWERS, IMAGE CAPTURING UNIT AND ELECTRONIC DEVICEAugust 2023June 2024Allow901NoNo
18236546PHOTOGRAPHING LENS ASSEMBLY INCLUDING EIGHT LENSES OF +-++--+-, +--++-+-, +--+--+-, +---+-+- OR +--+-++- REFRACTIVE POWERSAugust 2023March 2024Allow700NoNo
18366197OPTICAL IMAGING LENS INCLUDING EIGHT LENSES OF +-++-++-, +-++--+-, +-+---+- OR +-+-+-+- REFRACTIVE POWERSAugust 2023July 2024Allow1101NoNo
18332661SUPPRESSION OF STRAY LIGHT IN HEAD WORN COMPUTINGJune 2023March 2024Allow1000YesNo
18206572OPTICAL LENS ASSEMBLY COMPRISING SEVEN LENSES OF -++--+- OR +++--+- REFRACTIVE POWERS, IMAGE CAPTURING UNIT AND ELECTRONIC DEVICEJune 2023May 2024Allow1101YesNo
18204415Electrochromic Device and Method for Manufacturing Electrochromic DeviceJune 2023October 2024Abandon1610NoNo
18324982COMPACT DOUBLE FOLDED TELE CAMERAS INCLUDING FOUR LENSES OF +-+-, +-++ OR +--+; OR SIX LENSES OF +-+-+- OR +-+--- REFRACTIVE POWERSMay 2023January 2024Allow811YesNo
18314936LOW TOTAL TRACK LENGTH LENS ASSEMBLY INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF +-+-++- REFRACTIVE POWERS FOR LARGE SENSOR FORMATMay 2023January 2024Allow910YesNo
18306290OPTICAL LENS ASSEMBLY AND IMAGING DEVICE INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF ---++-+ OR ---+-++ REFRACTIVE POWERSApril 2023June 2025Allow2631YesNo
18297009ANTI-MYOPIA-PROGRESSION SPECTACLES AND ASSOCIATED METHODSApril 2023March 2024Allow1200YesNo
18125100OPTICAL LENS, OPTICAL MODULE, AND ELECTRONIC DEVICE INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF -+++-+- REFRACTIVE POWERSMarch 2023June 2025Allow2600NoNo
18184653VR EQUIPMENTMarch 2023June 2025Allow2700NoNo
18178806OPTICAL IMAGING LENS INCLUDING EIGHT LENSES OF +-+-++-- OR +-+--+--; OR NINE LENS OF +-+--+---, OR +-+-++--- REFRACTIVE POWERSMarch 2023January 2024Allow1001YesNo
18177824PHOTOGRAPHING OPTICAL LENS ASSEMBLY INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF +-++--+, +---+-+, +--+--+, +--++-+, +-+---+ OR +-+-+-- REFRACTIVE POWERS, IMAGE CAPTURING DEVICE AND ELECTRONIC DEVICEMarch 2023September 2023Allow700YesNo
18175131SYSTEMS AND METHODS FOR TESTING AND ANALYSIS OF VISUAL ACUITY AND ITS CHANGESFebruary 2023April 2025Allow2511YesNo
18101029IMAGING OPTICAL LENS ASSEMBLY INCLUDING NINE LENSES OF -++-++-+-, ++-++--+-, -+-++--+-, -+-++-++-, +--++--+- OR +--++-++- REFRACTIVE POWERS, IMAGE CAPTURING UNIT AND ELECTRONIC DEVICEJanuary 2023November 2023Allow1001YesNo
18148737OPTICAL SYSTEM AND IMAGE PICKUP APPARATUS HAVING THE SAME INCLUDING FIVE LENS UNITS OF +-++- or +--+- REFRACTIVE POWERSDecember 2022April 2025Allow2800NoNo
18089198IMAGING LENS SYSTEM, CAMERA MODULE AND ELECTRONIC DEVICEDecember 2022April 2024Allow1511YesNo
18074881OPTICAL IMAGING SYSTEM INCLUDING SIX LENSES OF +---++, OR SEVEN LENSES OF --+-++-, +-+--++, -++-+-- OR -++-++- REFRACTIVE POWERSDecember 2022August 2024Allow2021NoNo
18052596PHOTOGRAPHING OPTICAL LENS ASSEMBLY INCLUDING EIGHT LENSES OF +-+--++-, +-++-++-, ++++-++- OR +-+-+-+- REFRACTIVE POWERS, IMAGING APPARATUS AND ELECTRONIC DEVICENovember 2022November 2023Allow1301YesNo
17953345OPTICAL IMAGING LENS INCLUDING EIGHT LENSES OF +-+-+-+-, +-+-+-++, +-++--+-, OR +-+--++- REFRACTIVE POWERSSeptember 2022March 2024Allow1711YesNo
17953332OPTICAL IMAGING LENS INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF +--+-+- OR +--+++- REFRACTIVE POWERSSeptember 2022June 2024Allow2021YesNo
17892195OPTICAL IMAGING SYSTEM INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF +-+-++- OR +-+--+- REFRACTIVE POWERSAugust 2022April 2025Allow3241NoNo
17881696WIDE ANGLE LENS AND CAMERA SYSTEM FOR PERIPHERAL FIELD OF VIEW IMAGINGAugust 2022October 2024Abandon2621NoNo
17879431REFLECTIVE EYEPIECE OPTICAL SYSTEM AND HEAD-MOUNTED NEAR-TO-EYE DISPLAY DEVICEAugust 2022December 2022Allow400NoNo
17877276OPTICAL IMAGING SYSTEM INCLUDING EIGHT LENSES OF ++-+-+-- OR ++-+-++- REFRACTIVE POWERSJuly 2022February 2024Allow1810NoNo
17866534OPTICAL IMAGING LENS SYSTEM, IMAGE CAPTURING UNIT AND ELECTRONIC DEVICE INCLUDING SIX LENSES OF ++-++- OR ++--+- REFRACTIVE POWERSJuly 2022June 2025Allow3501YesNo
17810539APPARATUS FOR OPERATING A NON-LIGHT-EMITTING VARIABLE TRANSMISSION DEVICE AND A METHOD OF USING THE SAMEJuly 2022October 2023Abandon1610NoNo
17842273GRADIENT REFRACTIVE INDEX LENSES AND METHODS OF FABRICATING THE SAMEJune 2022March 2023Allow921NoNo
17835016PHOTOGRAPHING LENS SYSTEM, IMAGING APPARATUS AND ELECTRONIC DEVICE INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF --+--+- OR --+-++- REFRACTIVE POWERSJune 2022July 2023Allow1301YesNo
17833802OPTICAL IMAGING SYSTEM AND CAMERA DEVICE INCLUDING FIVE LENSES OF ++-+-, ++--- OR ++--+ REFRACTIVE POWERSJune 2022February 2024Allow2011YesNo
17829520OPTICAL IMAGING LENSJune 2022January 2025Abandon3141NoNo
17827665SYSTEMS AND METHODS FOR REDUCING STRAY LIGHT IN AUGMENTED REALITY AND RELATED APPLICATIONSMay 2022March 2024Allow2131YesNo
17723590OBJECTIVE OPTICAL SYSTEM FOR ENDOSCOPE AND ENDOSCOPE INCLUDING TWO LENS GROUP OF -+ REFRACTIVE POWERS HAVING SIXTH LENSES OF --+++- REFRACTIVE POWERSApril 2022September 2022Allow500NoNo
17722957OPTICAL LENS SYSTEM, IMAGE CAPTURING UNIT AND ELECTRONIC DEVICE COMPRISING NINE LENSES OF VARIOUS REFRACTIVE POWERS, OR TEN LENSES OF -+--+-+-+- OR ++--+-+-+- REFRACTIVE POWERSApril 2022August 2023Allow1601YesNo
17718336OPTICAL IMAGING LENS INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF +-+--+-, +-+-++- OR +---++- REFRACTIVE POWERSApril 2022March 2025Allow3501YesNo
17718341OPTICAL IMAGING LENS INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF +-++-+-, +-+--+-, +--+--+ OR +-++++- REFRACTIVE POWERSApril 2022June 2025Allow3901YesNo
17708954OPTICAL IMAGING LENS INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF --++-++ REFRACTIVE POWERSMarch 2022April 2025Allow3601YesNo
17762112LIGHT FIELD DISPLAY APPARATUSMarch 2022June 2025Allow3910YesNo
17753967LENS CURVATURE VARIATION APPARATUSMarch 2022February 2025Allow3500NoNo
17653655HOLLOW TRIPLE-PASS OPTICAL ELEMENTSMarch 2022October 2023Abandon2010YesNo
17687145HIGH RESOLUTION OPTICAL SYSTEM INCLUDING SIX LENSES OF +-+-+- REFRACTIVE POWERSMarch 2022September 2023Allow1911YesNo
17585929OPTICAL IMAGING SYSTEM HAVING SIX LENSES OF +-+-+- REFRACTIVE POWERSJanuary 2022October 2023Allow2111NoNo
17585995OPTICAL IMAGING SYSTEM INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF +---+-+ OR +--++-+ REFRACTIVE POWERSJanuary 2022October 2023Allow2130YesNo
17580188OPTICAL LENS COMPRISING TWO LENS GROUPS OF -+ REFRACTIVE POWERS HAVING SIX LENSES OF --+-++, -++-++, --++-+ OR --+-+- REFRACTIVE POWERSJanuary 2022October 2023Allow2111YesNo
17578775IMAGING LENS SYSTEM HAVING SEVEN LENSES OF +-+--+- OR +-+-++- REFRACTIVE POWERSJanuary 2022October 2023Allow2121YesNo
17577825IMAGING LENS SYSTEM INCLUDING FIVE LENSES OF +--+- OR +-++- REFRACTIVE POWERSJanuary 2022June 2025Allow4111YesNo
17564132ANTI-MYOPIA-PROGRESSION SPECTACLES AND ASSOCIATED METHODSDecember 2021April 2023Allow1600YesNo
17553739LIQUID CRYSTAL POLARIZATION HOLOGRAM (LCPH) BASED EYE TRACKING FOR AR/VRDecember 2021April 2025Allow4001YesNo
17546950IMAGING LENS SYSTEM AND IMAGING DEVICE COMPRISING SEVEN LENSES OF --++-+- REFRACTIVE POWERSDecember 2021September 2023Allow2220NoNo
17544230OPTICAL IMAGING SYSTEM INCLUDING EIGHT LENSES OF +++-+-+-, -++-+++- OR +-+-++-- REFRACTIVE POWERSDecember 2021July 2024Allow3130YesNo
17616710LENS DRIVING APPARATUS, CAMERA MODULE AND CAMERA-MOUNTED APPARATUSDecember 2021February 2025Allow3910YesNo
17537368DISPLAY DEVICE AND OPTICAL UNITNovember 2021January 2025Allow3801YesNo
17535744WIRE-GRID POLARIZER AND PROCESS FOR PRODUCING THE SAMENovember 2021October 2024Allow3511YesNo
17614380FOLDED MACRO-TELE CAMERA LENS DESIGNS INCLUDING SIX LENSES OF ++-+-+ OR +-++-+, SEVEN LENSES OF ++-++-+, OR EIGHT LENSES OF ++-++-++ REFRACTIVE POWERSNovember 2021October 2023Allow2321YesNo
17535647CAMERA OPTICAL LENS INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF +--+-+- REFRACTIVE POWERSNovember 2021May 2024Allow3000YesNo
17535294CAMERA LENS ASSEMBLY COMPRISING FOUR LENSES OF +-++, ++-+ OR +--+ REFRACTIVE POWERSNovember 2021February 2025Allow3860YesNo
17530636Lens Having a Fixed Focal Length and Constant Overall Length for Auto Focus Applications Including Five Lens Groups of ++--+, -++-+, -+++-, -++--, +-+--, +-++- or ++++- Refractive PowersNovember 2021April 2025Allow4111NoNo
17607400FOLDED CAMERA LENS DESIGNS INCLUDING EIGHT LENSES OF +-+-+++- REFRACTIVE POWERSOctober 2021May 2024Allow3031YesNo
17513862ANTI-MYOPIA-PROGRESSION SPECTACLES AND ASSOCIATED METHODSOctober 2021March 2023Allow1600YesNo
17506391IMAGING OPTICAL LENS SYSTEM INCLUDING EIGHT LENSES OF +-+--++-, +-+-+-+-, +-+++-+- OR +-+---+- REFRACTIVE POWERS, IMAGE CAPTURING UNIT AND ELECTRONIC DEVICEOctober 2021August 2024Allow3401YesNo
17451229Optical Image Capturing System Including Four Lenses of ++-- or +-+- Refractive PowersOctober 2021July 2024Allow3301NoNo
17603407SYSTEMS AND METHODS FOR SAMPLE POSITIONING TO FACILITATE MICROSCOPYOctober 2021February 2025Allow4101YesNo
17499312OPTICAL IMAGE CAPTURING SYSTEM INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF -+-++-+, -+++-++ OR --++-++ REFRACTIVE POWERSOctober 2021January 2025Allow3911NoNo
17602716CAMERA MODULE AND CAMERA APPARATUS COMPRISING SAMEOctober 2021January 2025Allow3911NoNo
17495275LENS DEVICEOctober 2021September 2024Allow3500NoNo
17449874BUILDING OF OPTOMECHANICAL SYSTEMS USING SELF-ALIGNED REFERENCE BALLSOctober 2021September 2024Allow3500NoNo
17493175OPTICAL LENS ASSEMBLY AND IMAGING DEVICE INCLUDING FIVE LENSES OF -++-+, +++-+, -++-- OR -+-+- REFRACTIVE POWERSOctober 2021May 2025Allow4421NoNo
17593942CAMERA MODULESeptember 2021June 2025Allow4411NoNo
17485873REFRACTION MEASURING APPARATUSSeptember 2021November 2024Allow3701YesNo
17479365OPTICAL SYSTEM AND IMAGING DEVICE INCLUDING TWO LENS GROUPS OF -+ REFRACTIVE POWERSSeptember 2021October 2024Allow3701NoNo
17439632LENS DRIVING DEVICESeptember 2021March 2025Allow4111YesNo
17471905OPTICAL SYSTEM, LENS MODULE, AND TERMINAL DEVICE INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF ++--+--,+-+-+--,++-++--,++--++- OR ++--+-+ REFRACTIVE POWERSSeptember 2021July 2024Allow3410YesNo
17438265OPTICAL LENS, CAMERA MODULE AND MANUFACTURING METHOD THEREOFSeptember 2021June 2025Allow4521YesNo
17458748WIDE-ANGLE LENS INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF --+++-+ OR -++++-+ REFRACTIVE POWERSAugust 2021July 2024Allow3401YesNo
17408749OPTICAL IMAGING SYSTEM COMPRISING FOUR LENSES OF ++++ REFRACTIVE POWERSAugust 2021November 2023Allow2721NoNo
17406811IMAGING LENS INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF ++-++-- OR ++-+++- REFRACTIVE POWERSAugust 2021March 2024Allow3100NoNo
17406130OPTICAL IMAGING SYSTEM INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF VARIOUS REFRACTIVE POWERSAugust 2021September 2024Allow3721NoNo
17403640OPTICAL IMAGING SYSTEM COMPRISING FOUR LENES OF --+-, +-+-, +++- OR -++- REFRACTIVE POWERS, IMAGE CAPTURING UNIT AND ELECTRONIC DEVICEAugust 2021May 2023Allow2101NoNo
17403618OPTICAL LENS ASSEMBLY COMPRISING SEVEN LENSES OF -++--+- OR +++--+- REFRACTIVE POWERS, IMAGE CAPTURING UNIT AND ELECTRONIC DEVICEAugust 2021March 2023Allow1900YesNo
17403261OPTICAL IMAGING LENS ASSEMBLY INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF -+-+-+- OR -+-+--- REFRACTIVE POWERSAugust 2021October 2024Allow3811YesNo
17391968IMAGING LENS INCLUDING SEVEN LENSES OF +-+0+--, +-+0-+- OR +-+0++- REFRACTIVE POWERSAugust 2021January 2024Allow2911YesNo
17391852IMAGING LENS COMPRISING SEVEN LENSES OF +-+--+- OR +++--+- REFRACTIVE POWERSAugust 2021January 2024Allow3010YesNo
17391780IMAGING LENSAugust 2021March 2023Allow2000YesNo
17391840IMAGING LENS COMPRISING SEVEN LENSES OF -+--++-, -+-+++-, ++--++-, ++--+-- OR ++--++- REFRACTIVE POWERSAugust 2021July 2024Allow3521NoNo
17391748IMAGING LENS INCLUDING SIX LENSES OF +----+, +--+-+ OR +---+- REFRACTIVE POWERSAugust 2021January 2024Allow2911YesNo
17391819IMAGING LENS INCLUDING FIVE LENSES OF +-0+- REFRACTIVE POWERSAugust 2021July 2023Allow2301YesNo
17388597PHOTOGRAPHING LENS ASSEMBLY, IMAGE CAPTURING UNIT AND ELECTRONIC DEVICE INCLUDING EIGHT LENSES OF +-++--+-, +--++-+-, +--+--+-, +---+-+- OR +--+-++- REFRACTIVE POWERSJuly 2021May 2023Allow2201NoNo
17387369SYSTEMS, DEVICES, AND METHODS FOR SIDE LOBE CONTROL IN HOLOGRAMSJuly 2021March 2024Allow3121NoNo

Appeals Overview

This analysis examines appeal outcomes and the strategic value of filing appeals for examiner HUANG, WEN.

Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) Decisions

Total PTAB Decisions
1
Examiner Affirmed
1
(100.0%)
Examiner Reversed
0
(0.0%)
Reversal Percentile
12.5%
Lower than average

What This Means

With a 0.0% reversal rate, the PTAB affirms the examiner's rejections in the vast majority of cases. This reversal rate is in the bottom 25% across the USPTO, indicating that appeals face significant challenges here.

Strategic Value of Filing an Appeal

Total Appeal Filings
19
Allowed After Appeal Filing
8
(42.1%)
Not Allowed After Appeal Filing
11
(57.9%)
Filing Benefit Percentile
67.5%
Higher than average

Understanding Appeal Filing Strategy

Filing a Notice of Appeal can sometimes lead to allowance even before the appeal is fully briefed or decided by the PTAB. This occurs when the examiner or their supervisor reconsiders the rejection during the mandatory appeal conference (MPEP § 1207.01) after the appeal is filed.

In this dataset, 42.1% of applications that filed an appeal were subsequently allowed. This appeal filing benefit rate is above the USPTO average, suggesting that filing an appeal can be an effective strategy for prompting reconsideration.

Strategic Recommendations

Appeals to PTAB face challenges. Ensure your case has strong merit before committing to full Board review.

Filing a Notice of Appeal is strategically valuable. The act of filing often prompts favorable reconsideration during the mandatory appeal conference.

Examiner HUANG, WEN - Prosecution Strategy Guide

Executive Summary

Examiner HUANG, WEN works in Art Unit 2872 and has examined 822 patent applications in our dataset. With an allowance rate of 86.6%, this examiner has an above-average tendency to allow applications. Applications typically reach final disposition in approximately 27 months.

Allowance Patterns

Examiner HUANG, WEN's allowance rate of 86.6% places them in the 60% percentile among all USPTO examiners. This examiner has an above-average tendency to allow applications.

Office Action Patterns

On average, applications examined by HUANG, WEN receive 1.24 office actions before reaching final disposition. This places the examiner in the 22% percentile for office actions issued. This examiner issues significantly fewer office actions than most examiners.

Prosecution Timeline

The median time to disposition (half-life) for applications examined by HUANG, WEN is 27 months. This places the examiner in the 58% percentile for prosecution speed. Prosecution timelines are slightly faster than average with this examiner.

Interview Effectiveness

Conducting an examiner interview provides a +21.5% benefit to allowance rate for applications examined by HUANG, WEN. This interview benefit is in the 70% percentile among all examiners. Recommendation: Interviews provide an above-average benefit with this examiner and are worth considering.

Request for Continued Examination (RCE) Effectiveness

When applicants file an RCE with this examiner, 33.1% of applications are subsequently allowed. This success rate is in the 64% percentile among all examiners. Strategic Insight: RCEs show above-average effectiveness with this examiner. Consider whether your amendments or new arguments are strong enough to warrant an RCE versus filing a continuation.

After-Final Amendment Practice

This examiner enters after-final amendments leading to allowance in 19.3% of cases where such amendments are filed. This entry rate is in the 16% percentile among all examiners. Strategic Recommendation: This examiner rarely enters after-final amendments compared to other examiners. You should generally plan to file an RCE or appeal rather than relying on after-final amendment entry. Per MPEP § 714.12, primary examiners have discretion in entering after-final amendments, and this examiner exercises that discretion conservatively.

Pre-Appeal Conference Effectiveness

When applicants request a pre-appeal conference (PAC) with this examiner, 175.0% result in withdrawal of the rejection or reopening of prosecution. This success rate is in the 92% percentile among all examiners. Strategic Recommendation: Pre-appeal conferences are highly effective with this examiner compared to others. Before filing a full appeal brief, strongly consider requesting a PAC. The PAC provides an opportunity for the examiner and supervisory personnel to reconsider the rejection before the case proceeds to the PTAB.

Appeal Withdrawal and Reconsideration

This examiner withdraws rejections or reopens prosecution in 94.4% of appeals filed. This is in the 83% percentile among all examiners. Of these withdrawals, 47.1% occur early in the appeal process (after Notice of Appeal but before Appeal Brief). Strategic Insight: This examiner frequently reconsiders rejections during the appeal process compared to other examiners. Per MPEP § 1207.01, all appeals must go through a mandatory appeal conference. Filing a Notice of Appeal may prompt favorable reconsideration even before you file an Appeal Brief.

Petition Practice

When applicants file petitions regarding this examiner's actions, 48.6% are granted (fully or in part). This grant rate is in the 58% percentile among all examiners. Strategic Note: Petitions show above-average success regarding this examiner's actions. Petitionable matters include restriction requirements (MPEP § 1002.02(c)(2)) and various procedural issues.

Examiner Cooperation and Flexibility

Examiner's Amendments: This examiner makes examiner's amendments in 0.0% of allowed cases (in the 25% percentile). This examiner rarely makes examiner's amendments compared to other examiners. You should expect to make all necessary claim amendments yourself through formal amendment practice.

Quayle Actions: This examiner issues Ex Parte Quayle actions in 3.9% of allowed cases (in the 75% percentile). Per MPEP § 714.14, a Quayle action indicates that all claims are allowable but formal matters remain. This examiner frequently uses Quayle actions compared to other examiners, which is a positive indicator that once substantive issues are resolved, allowance follows quickly.

Prosecution Strategy Recommendations

Based on the statistical analysis of this examiner's prosecution patterns, here are tailored strategic recommendations:

  • Plan for RCE after final rejection: This examiner rarely enters after-final amendments. Budget for an RCE in your prosecution strategy if you receive a final rejection.
  • Request pre-appeal conferences: PACs are highly effective with this examiner. Before filing a full appeal brief, request a PAC to potentially resolve issues without full PTAB review.
  • Appeal filing as negotiation tool: This examiner frequently reconsiders rejections during the appeal process. Filing a Notice of Appeal may prompt favorable reconsideration during the mandatory appeal conference.

Relevant MPEP Sections for Prosecution Strategy

  • MPEP § 713.10: Examiner interviews - available before Notice of Allowance or transfer to PTAB
  • MPEP § 714.12: After-final amendments - may be entered "under justifiable circumstances"
  • MPEP § 1002.02(c): Petitionable matters to Technology Center Director
  • MPEP § 1004: Actions requiring primary examiner signature (allowances, final rejections, examiner's answers)
  • MPEP § 1207.01: Appeal conferences - mandatory for all appeals
  • MPEP § 1214.07: Reopening prosecution after appeal

Important Disclaimer

Not Legal Advice: The information provided in this report is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. You should consult with a qualified patent attorney or agent for advice specific to your situation.

No Guarantees: We do not provide any guarantees as to the accuracy, completeness, or timeliness of the statistics presented above. Patent prosecution statistics are derived from publicly available USPTO data and are subject to data quality limitations, processing errors, and changes in USPTO practices over time.

Limitation of Liability: Under no circumstances will IronCrow AI be liable for any outcome, decision, or action resulting from your reliance on the statistics, analysis, or recommendations presented in this report. Past prosecution patterns do not guarantee future results.

Use at Your Own Risk: While we strive to provide accurate and useful prosecution statistics, you should independently verify any information that is material to your prosecution strategy and use your professional judgment in all patent prosecution matters.